UNP

Railroads · Report · 2023

Union Pacific Corp

A Dividend Growth Investment Thesis

~114% potential 10-yr return
100+ yr dividend track record
9 min read

This summary reflects our report as written in 2023. Figures and views have not been updated since.

In 1869 the transcontinental railway was completed, and suddenly the U.S. became much smaller. Ever since, railroads have been an integral part of the U.S. economy.

We believe railroads are attractive long-term investments due to their wide-moat businesses that keep disruption at a minimum. We also believe they possess a rare combination of longevity and staying power. While railroads may lack glamour, they have demonstrated the capacity to consistently generate cash flow and build substantial wealth for shareholders.

At Denewiler Capital Management, our core investment strategy is to increase portfolio income by investing in companies that sustainably grow their dividends year after year. We consider Union Pacific Corp the most appealing choice among its peers, primarily because of its 2.5% dividend yield. Company management has historically shown the ability to consistently increase its dividend without sacrificing the earnings power of the company, and we believe that will continue.

UNP is not entirely devoid of risk. We anticipate a potential return of approximately 114% over the next decade based on the growth of its dividend and overall business performance.

The short version There are only six Class I railroads in the US. New entrants face limited land leases and prohibitive track costs. That creates scarcity and provides pricing power.

Territory & Background

Union Pacific was formed in 1862 when President Lincoln signed the company's charter. It went on to contribute significantly to the westward expansion of the US economy, leaving a lasting impact.

UNP faced bankruptcy in 1893 alongside 153 other railroads. It has since evolved into a remarkable tale of dividend growth success. It boasts a dividend track record of more than 100 years.

There are only six Class I railroads in the US, and they all operate as a regional duopoly. Five of the companies are publicly traded, while BNSF is privately owned by Berkshire Hathaway.

Even though each company has a specified territory, the national rail network is intricately connected. Since there is limited track space, the railroads must coordinate the use of some assets. They compete against each other. They also jointly own assets such as bridges, terminals, and stretches of track.

According to Union Pacific's public disclosures, it shares 50% ownership of several assets with its direct competitor BNSF. These include the Alameda Belt, Houston Belt & Terminal and Longview Switching Co., among others. This type of symbiotic relationship is common within the industry.

The regional pairings are BNSF and UNP in the West, CSX and NSC in the East, and CNR and CP in the North.

The American railroad industry is highly established, with limited opportunities for new entrants. The US Government is unlikely to grant additional land leases. The unsubsidized cost of laying extensive new track is prohibitively expensive. Although the industry has undergone consolidation, additional mergers may raise concerns under antitrust laws.

While this may appear to limit future growth for the industry, it creates scarcity and provides pricing power.

Transporting goods by train has cost, environmental, and delivery advantages in a variety of applications. According to the Congressional Budget Office, moving products via rail is 60-70% cheaper than trucks. UNP carries 165,000 carloads of freight per week. One train can carry the equivalent of 300 trucks worth of freight.

Railroads move one ton of freight over 500 miles on one gallon of fuel on average, making them four times more efficient than trucks. Based on 2021 EPA data, railways contribute 2% to greenhouse gas emissions in the transportation sector. Aircraft constitute 8% and medium/heavy-duty trucks represent 23%.

Top & Bottom Line

Union Pacific generates annual revenue of $24.88 billion, which is more than double some of its peers. Revenue growth across the railroad industry has been nominal over the past decade. A lack of top-line growth does not necessarily imply a lack of overall company expansion.

UNP has significantly improved its operational efficiency, which has expanded its profit margins. Consequently, UNP's net income has increased at a much faster pace than its overall revenue.

Net Income, Most Recent Annual ($B)
UNP
$6.998B
CNI
$3.934B
CSX
$4.166B
NSC
$3.27B
CP
$2.703B
02468

Values are the most recent annual figures from the 10 Year Net Income chart in the report.

Margin enhancement translates to higher free cash flow. More free cash flow creates opportunities to reinvest in the business, repurchase shares, reduce debt, or increase the dividend.

Return on Invested Capital

Return on invested capital is a way to measure how well a company manages its capital. A number above 10% generally means that over time a company is earning returns greater than its cost of capital. When evaluating candidates for robust dividend growth, we usually establish a minimum threshold of 10% as a decisive criterion.

Union Pacific has consistently exceeded this 10% benchmark over the last decade, showcasing both reliability and the capacity to return cash to shareholders.

History of UNP's Return on Invested Capital
0%5%10%15%20%25%30%
'10'11'12'13'14'15'16'17'18'19'20'21'22

10% benchmark. Year-end values, 12/31/10 through 12/31/22. The bars reproduce the chart in the report, which does not label individual values.

Debt & Free Cash Flow

Union Pacific carries a total debt load of $33 billion, with around 25% or $8.25 billion coming due within the next five years. A 2% increase in interest rates would only increase its debt costs by $160 million annually through 2025. That is a very manageable number considering UNP has over $8 billion in operating cash flow.

UNP has a times-interest-earned ratio of 7.5, which means it has 7.5 times more EBIT than is required to pay its annual interest cost. Over the last decade, Union Pacific has consistently excelled in producing noteworthy and positive free cash flow.

A Dividend Success Story

Union Pacific's dividend policy is a key factor in why we consider it an attractive investment. Over the past few decades, UNP has consistently raised its dividend, achieving a 10-year annualized growth rate of 15.1% and a 20-year annualized growth rate of 17.4%.

Even though we expect a slowdown in its dividend growth rate from its 20-year average, we find an average of 7% per year highly achievable over the next 10 or 20 years.

For dividends to increase, there must be a corresponding growth in earnings. Since 2012, earnings per share (EPS) has experienced 200% growth. Over the last two decades, earnings have surged from $0.94 to $10.42.

Our model assumes a 7% annual growth rate for the dividend. Under that assumption, the dividend is projected to reach $9.56 by 2032. Analysts estimate 2025 earnings of $12.84, which implies a payout ratio of 46% against our projected dividend of $5.95. That is a rough average of what Union Pacific has maintained over the last ten years.

YearProjected Dividend
2023$5.20
2024$5.56
2025$5.95
2026$6.37
2027$6.82
2028$7.29
2029$7.80
2030$8.35
2031$8.93
2032$9.56
Model Inputs and Result
UNP Purchase Price$212.38
Dividend Growth7.0%
Total Dividends$71.85
Forecasted Terminal Yield2.5%
Implied Stock Price$382.40
10 Year Total Return114%

The estimated 2.5% terminal dividend yield is derived by projecting the current yield to 2032. To calculate the 10-year return, we add the total dividend income over the period to the implied stock price based on the projected dividend yield. The total return without compounding would be approximately 114%.

Why We Own It

We opt for UNP over the other publicly traded railroads primarily because it aligns with our dividend growth criteria. It also appears healthy enough to maintain that going forward.

  • Replicating a railroad and laying a competing track of length is an exceedingly challenging task. As a result, railroads are positioned with one of the lowest risks of disruption compared to other industries.
  • Trains have a shipping cost advantage over trucks of about 5.1 cents versus 15.6 cents per mile.
  • The continuation of share buybacks will contribute to the further growth of earnings per share. Due to potential antitrust challenges in acquiring another major railroad, railroads are somewhat compelled to emphasize returning capital to shareholders.
  • UNP has low interest rate risk since 75% of its debt matures after 5 years.
  • There is limited regulation risk due to the importance of trains to the American economy.
  • With a new CEO boasting 40 years of industry experience, Jim Vena has been recognized for implementing the Precision Railroading Method. Under his leadership, there is a specific emphasis on reducing dwell times and enhancing asset utilization.

While there is no assurance that railroads, particularly UNP, will sustain their past performance, we believe there are compelling reasons for a dividend growth investor to consider UNP. However, it is crucial to take into consideration the price you pay.

Valuation

In our view, Union Pacific presents itself as a strong candidate for dividend growth. To increase the likelihood of exceeding our total return hurdle rate, it is important that we exercise discipline with our investment.

At around $200 per share, UNP would trade below the 10-year average of price-to-free-cash-flow and price-to-earnings. To paraphrase Buffett, it is usually better to buy a great business at a fair price rather than a fair business at a great price. We will attempt to take a full position in UNP if it falls below $200.

Risks

There are risks associated with every investment. Beyond market risks such as changes in interest rates or an extended economic downturn, we identify the following risks with UNP.

Derailments and toxic waste spills

This is likely the most serious factor that directly poses a risk to the stock and financial performance. A recent example is the Norfolk Southern derailment in East Palestine, Ohio, that occurred on February 3, 2023.

Regulation resulting in higher safety and track spending

All else equal, this would likely contract margins and reduce profitability. It would also make it more difficult to grow the dividend. We find that the likelihood of this risk causing material change to the industry is low, though it is ever present.

Other business risks

These include strikes, labor, and fuel costs. They also include the inability to pass through inflationary cost pressures.

Investing is inherently uncertain, and there are always company-specific risks that remain unknowable. Nevertheless, we perceive UNP as having strong potential to achieve both dividend growth and an attractive total return over a 10-year horizon.

Get the full analysis

The complete Union Pacific investment report as a PDF, delivered instantly.

Sources, as listed in the report:
Association of American Railroads, The Economic Impact of a Railroad Shutdown, Sept. 2022.
EPA, "Fast Facts on Transportation Greenhouse Gas Emissions," accessed Nov. 2023.
Union Pacific, "Pros & Cons of Rail: Shipping Cost, Speed, Capacity and More," accessed Nov. 2023.
SEC.gov, Burlington Northern Santa Fe 10-K for year ending Dec. 31, 2022.
SEC.gov, Union Pacific Corp. 10-K for year ending Dec. 31, 2022.
Union Pacific Investor Relations, accessed Nov. 2023.
Union Pacific Railroad, Class I Railroad Annual Report R-1, 2022.
YCharts data, accessed Nov. 2023.
This report is for educational purposes only. It is not a recommendation to buy or sell the company or companies mentioned herein, and it does not imply any sort of guaranteed investment return. Stocks, whether they pay a dividend or not, can lose money or value. Dividend investing does not imply any sort of superior returns over other stock investments or strategies. Every investment should be carefully considered based on your own personal risk profile, investment goals, and circumstances. No investment should be considered solely on its own merits but as a part of a diversified portfolio. Denewiler Capital Management may or may not have positions in the publicly traded companies mentioned herein.

Talk To Us

Compounding your wealth starts here.

Book a 15-30 minute introduction. No pressure, no obligation.

Schedule an Introduction

Get In Touch